For club officers

How to Keep Club Members Engaged After Their First Event

In our check-in data, 59% of people came to one event and never came back. Here's how to turn more first-timers into regulars, starting the day after their first visit.

Arden Pala

Arden Pala, founder of Helptivo

Updated · 4 min read

In short

  • In our data from 7 clubs, about 6 in 10 people came to one event and never again, about 4 in 10 came back, and 1 in 4 came three or more times.
  • The second visit is the one to win. Message every first-timer within a day with the exact date of the next event.
  • When they come back, introduce them to someone and give them a small job.
  • Watch your regulars too. A personal message after three missed meetings in a row catches people before they drift off.

Someone new walks into your meeting, stays the whole time, laughs at the right moments, and you never see them again.

This post is about that gap between a first visit and a second one. It's the cheapest place to grow a club, because these people already came once.

How many first-timers come back

We looked at the 7 clubs on Helptivo that ran at least four events with QR check-in. 858 different people checked in at those events.

How many events each person came to
Came toShare of people
One event only58.5%
Two or more events41.5%
Three or more events24.6%

Helptivo data: 858 people who checked in by QR code at 7 clubs that ran 4 or more QR events, February to November 2026. Test and demo accounts excluded. The three-or-more group is part of the two-or-more group.

So more than half the people who tried one of these clubs didn't come back. It's a small group of clubs, so read it as a rough picture. But it shows where the work is: getting someone from their first visit to their second.

By the second visit, someone knows a few names and what a meeting looks like. Coming a third time is an easier ask than the second.

Message every first-timer within a day

The day after an event, look at who came for the first time and send each of them a short message. A text or DM from an officer, using their name, beats any group email.

Put the next date in it. "Hope to see you again!" is easy to ignore. "Next meeting is Thursday at 4 in room 210, come find me" is a plan they can say yes to.

Welcome message to a first-timer

Hey [Name]! It was really nice having you at [event] yesterday, thanks for coming.

Our next [meeting/event] is [Day] at [Time] in [Place]. [One line on what's happening, e.g. "We're picking the date for the spring food drive."]

If you want, come find me when you get there and I'll introduce you to a few people. And if you have any questions about the club, just reply here!

[Your name], [your role]

Send it from your own phone or account the day after. If they mentioned something they liked, add a line about it.

Split the list between officers so nobody sends more than a handful. Each officer should take the people they actually talked to.

Make the second visit easy

  • Meet them at the door. The officer who sent the message should look out for them and introduce them to one regular, ideally someone in their grade, major or class.
  • Give them a small job. Hand out name tags, hold the check-in code, take photos, keep time. A job gives people a reason to come and something to do while they don't know anyone yet.
  • Explain the basics again. Spend one minute on who the officers are and what the club is working on this month. Regulars won't mind hearing it twice.
  • Skip the inside jokes early on. They're fun for the people who get them and a wall for everyone else.

Keep a schedule people can remember

People can't come back if they don't know when the next thing is. Meet on the same day, at the same time, in the same place whenever you can. Say the next date out loud at the end of every meeting.

Post the whole semester's dates once, early, and pin them in the group chat. When a date changes, say so in its own message instead of burying it in a long update. For more on picking times that work, see our guide to getting better attendance at events.

Give regulars something to own

Once someone has come three or more times, they're part of the group that keeps the club going. In the data above, that was about one person in four. Ask them to lead something small: run one meeting's activity, plan a social, or be the contact for a partner organization.

Giving people a job is also how you find next year's officers. Our post on why clubs fade out covers that handoff.

Notice when regulars stop coming

The other half of keeping people is catching the ones who drift. If someone who came every week has missed three in a row, send a quick personal message. Keep it light, with no guilt: "We missed you the last few weeks, everything okay? Next one's Thursday."

Sometimes it's a new job or a class that moved, and you can't fix that. Sometimes it's a meeting time you could change. Either way, they know someone noticed.

That only works if you know who's missing. If you're not tracking attendance by person yet, our guide to tracking member engagement has a simple sheet layout for it.

How we handle this in Helptivo

In Helptivo, new sign-ups and walk-ins show up next to your member list, so after an event you can see who's new. You can sort members by Least Active over the last 30 days, and your Overview shows a Next Steps card when members have missed their last 3 events.

We don't message members for you. The welcome text still comes from a real person, and that's the part that works.

The member list, with the newest sign-ups and walk-ins beside it. (Tap to enlarge.)

Questions people ask

Why do club members stop coming?

Usually small things: a schedule clash, not knowing anyone, or nobody noticing they were there. In our data, 59% of people who checked in came to just one event, so the week after a first visit is where to focus.

How do you get new members to come back?

Message them personally within a day with the exact date, time and place of the next event. When they show up again, introduce them to someone and give them a small job.

What should a welcome message to a new member say?

Their name, thanks for coming, the date, time and place of the next event, and an offer to introduce them to people. Keep it to four or five lines and send it from a real person, not a club account.

How many members usually stay active?

In our data from 7 clubs, about 25% of the people who checked in came to three or more events. It's a small sample, so track your own club's numbers too.

Written by Arden Pala

Arden started Helptivo after running Sports4Kids, a youth sports nonprofit, on spreadsheets, Google Forms and group chats. He builds Helptivo and writes these guides from what clubs run into on it.

Run your club in one place

Sign-ups, QR check-in, hours and reports. Free for clubs with up to 150 members, with no time limit and no card needed.

Try Helptivo free

Keep reading