For club officers deciding how to keep records

Helptivo vs Google Sheets for Running a Club: An Honest Comparison

Google Sheets is free, flexible and already in everyone's account. Here's where it's the better choice, where it starts to hurt, and what Helptivo does that a spreadsheet can't do on its own.

Arden Pala

Arden Pala, founder of Helptivo

Updated · 5 min read

In short

  • Google Sheets is the better pick for a small club with one record keeper, for custom tracking like a budget, or when your sheet already works.
  • On its own, a sheet can't let members check in from their phones, work out hours from check-in times, or email everyone who came to an event.
  • Helptivo does those things and is free for up to 150 members, 250 emails a month and 3 team members.
  • You can also use both: Helptivo for people and events, a sheet for money.

If your club runs on a Google Sheet right now, you're in good company. I ran Sports4Kids on spreadsheets, Google Forms and group chats. The sheet was never the problem on the first day. It became the problem when I needed to know who signed up, who actually came, and how many hours each person had earned.

You don't need to delete your spreadsheet after reading this. Below is a straight comparison, including the cases where Sheets wins.

When Google Sheets is the better pick

Google Sheets is free, everyone already knows how to use it, and you can make it track anything. Those are real advantages. Stick with it if any of these sound like you:

  • Your club is small and one person keeps the records. A 12-person club with one secretary can keep a clean sheet for years.
  • You track something unusual. A budget, a dues ledger, a tournament bracket or a reading list. A spreadsheet bends to whatever you need. Helptivo is built around members, events and hours, and it doesn't do dues or money.
  • Your sheet already works. If the formulas are set up, the next officers know where it lives, and nobody is stuck doing data entry at midnight, don't switch for the sake of it.
  • You want full control. You decide every column. Nothing changes unless you change it.

Small is normal, too. Most clubs on Helptivo are small: more than 80% of the ones that have run an event (85 of 104) have fewer than 25 members. Size alone isn't a reason to switch.

What a spreadsheet can't do on its own

The trouble usually comes from the work around the sheet, the parts you end up doing by hand.

Check-in from people's phones

A sheet doesn't give members a page to check themselves in. You either type names in at the door, pass around paper and copy it later, or build a Google Form for check-in and send it to a linked sheet. That last one works, but it's one more form per event, and names come in spelled three different ways.

Hours that add themselves up

To track service hours in a sheet, someone records start and end times for each person and keeps a formula working. That's fine for 10 people. For 60 people across a semester of events, one pasted row in the wrong place throws off a total, and you find out when a member asks why their hours look low.

Emails tied to an event

"Email everyone who came to Saturday's cleanup" means filtering the sheet, copying the addresses and pasting them into BCC. It's doable. It's also the step that gets skipped when you're busy.

Several officers editing at once

Sheets handles shared editing well, and it keeps version history so you can restore an earlier version or see a cell's edit history. The harder problem is copies. Someone downloads it, edits offline, or makes "Members FINAL v2," and now you have two lists.

Side by side

JobGoogle SheetsHelptivo
PriceFreeFree up to 150 members, 250 emails a month, 3 team members. Pro $9.99 a month, Growth $19.99 a month
Member listAny columns you wantName, email, phone, notes, flags, plus hours and events attended filled in for you
Event sign-upsNeeds a Google Form per eventA sign-up page per event, with a capacity limit
Check-inTyped in, paper, or a separate formMembers scan a QR code on their phone
HoursFormulas you set up and maintainWorked out from the event or from check-in and check-out times
EmailsCopy addresses into GmailSend to all members, an event's attendees, or a flag group
Budget, dues, custom trackingYes, anythingNo dues or money tracking. Custom impact numbers are typed in by hand
Shifts and time slotsYes, if you build themNo shifts or slots

If you're staying on Sheets, set it up like this

A common mess is one tab that tries to do everything. Three tabs, linked by email address, hold up much better. Use email as the key in every tab, because names get misspelled and emails mostly don't.

Club tracker layout for Google Sheets

TAB 1: MEMBERS (one row per person)
Email | First name | Last name | Phone | Grade or year | Joined (date) | Role | Notes

TAB 2: EVENTS (one row per event)
Event ID | Event name | Date | Start time | End time | Location | Lead officer | Signed up | Came

TAB 3: ATTENDANCE (one row per person per event)
Event ID | Email | Signed up? (Y/N) | Came? (Y/N) | Check-in time | Check-out time | Hours

RULES
- Email is the key. Never type a name without an email next to it.
- One file, owned by the club Google account. No downloaded copies.
- Hours = (check-out minus check-in) x 24, rounded to 0.25.
- Fill in Attendance the same day as the event.
- Total hours per member = SUMIF on the Attendance tab, not typed by hand.

Keep the file in a Drive folder the club owns, not an officer's school account.

What switching to Helptivo involves

If you decide to move, you don't have to retype anything. Google Sheets lets you download your spreadsheet as an .xlsx file, and Helptivo imports .xlsx with name, email, phone and notes columns. It doesn't take CSV files, so download the Excel version.

Past hours don't come across in the import. If members need their old totals, add them as manual hours on their profiles, or use bulk Add Hours.

How we handle this in Helptivo

Members sign up on the event page, then scan a QR code at the door. Helptivo marks them as attended and works out their hours from the event length, or from their check-in and check-out times if you use Full Tracking.

If you'd rather check people off yourself, Manual Verification lets you untick no-shows and fix hours after the event. Either way, each member's total updates on their profile, so there's no formula to break.

After an event you can untick anyone who didn't come and edit hours before they count. (Tap to enlarge.)

How to decide

Ask one question: who is doing the typing, and how long does it take them each week? If the answer is "one person, ten minutes," keep your sheet. If it's "whoever is free, and it takes an evening after every event," the sheet is costing you more than it looks.

You can also try both. Run one event with QR check-in while your sheet stays as it is, then compare how long the after-event work took. That tells you more than any comparison table.

Questions people ask

Is Google Sheets good enough to run a club?

For a small club with one person keeping the records, yes. It starts to strain when several officers edit it, when you need people to check themselves in, or when you have to add up hours for a lot of members.

Is Helptivo free?

Yes, for clubs with up to 150 members, 250 emails a month and 3 team members. Pro is $9.99 a month and Growth is $19.99 a month for bigger clubs.

Can I move my Google Sheet into Helptivo?

Yes. Download the sheet as an .xlsx file and import it. Helptivo reads name, email, phone and notes columns. It does not import CSV files.

Can I use Helptivo and Google Sheets together?

Yes. You can keep a budget or dues sheet in Google Sheets and use Helptivo for members, sign-ups, check-in and hours. Helptivo reports export to Excel and CSV if you want the numbers in a sheet.

Written by Arden Pala

Arden started Helptivo after running Sports4Kids, a youth sports nonprofit, on spreadsheets, Google Forms and group chats. He builds Helptivo and writes these guides from what clubs run into on it.

Run your club in one place

Sign-ups, QR check-in, hours and reports. Free for clubs with up to 150 members, with no time limit and no card needed.

Try Helptivo free

Keep reading